The East Enders

Baron's Cove & The Pridwin

Our sister properties on Long Island offer a wonderful gateway to the fabled East End. Each with a storied history and a waterfront location, both Baron's Cove and The Pridwin are eager to welcome you. Those who love our Cape May properties will feel right at home.
Baron’s Cove boasts 67 rooms and sits on the edge of the harbor in historic Sag Harbor. Opened in 1958, Baron’s Cove is celebrating its 65th anniversary this season. Baron’s is just a 5- minute walk to Sag Harbor’s charming Main Street. The bar is a local gathering place, hosting live music most nights each week; the wood burning hearth, is warm and inviting on any night there is a chill in the air. The high ceilinged, beamed dining room soars above the harbor and serves classic American fare as the American flag on the wooden flagpole clanks ever so softly outside in the breeze.

Two Images: one showing a beautiful fluffy dog with golden lox. The other showing a homey seating area with a lit fireplace and string lights hanging from the rafters.

Views from Baron's Cove
Sag Harbor, New York

The Pridwin, with its 16 private cottages and 33 main house rooms, sits high on Shelter Island overlooking the Peconic Bay. The seven-acre campus is a magical place. From the two docks and small pebble beach on the waterfront, to The Grove, a woodland amphitheater, to the chicken coop with fresh eggs, there is a surprise and delight around every corner. With a tennis court, pickleball, spa, fitness center, kayaks, paddleboards, bicycles, and a boat – wellness and activities abound. From the library and board game filled living room with a wood burning fireplace to the charming, spacious bar and sprawling porch overlooking the bay, relaxation abounds. We have come to love this place and know that you will too.

a plush seating area overlooking the bay

A bit of the grandeur of Congress Hall. A splash of the design sense of the Virginia. A piece of the pastoral beauty of Beach Plum Farm.

a luxurious American classic style bar with plush, red stools.

As you relax with us here in Cape May, we’d like to invite you to discover these new members of the Cape Resorts family. They’re everything you love about our Cape May properties—with the same sense of nostalgia, whimsy and wonder. It would be our pleasure to welcome you to the East End.

A lovely Hotel of white and green overlooking the bay

The Pridwin
Shelter Island, New York


Sorry, there are no current specials.