Join Us For

THE PRIDWIN HOTEL & COTTAGES
Available Friday, October 20 through Sunday, October 22, 2023
It’s 1927. You’ve taken your seat to dine at The Pridwin, Shelter Island’s newest resort. As you notice glasses clinking, you’re clued in to open secret: proprietor Dutch Schultz has opened a speakeasy on the property. His girlfriend, Lu Lu, is a regular fixture on the entertainment stage, much to the chagrin of local flapper, Rosie. . .
read moreThe night roars along nicely, until bullets crack and the law shows up. As the smoke clears, a body falls—and it doesn’t look like the Charleston did it! Now, it’s up to you to crack the case during this exciting weekend at The Pridwin.
Spend a two-night stay with us and watch the mystery unfold as you experience three days filled with riddles, clues and a whodunit that will keep you guessing until the very end. From costumes and storylines to humor and problem solving, our partners at Murder Cafe will be sure to entertain and surprise guests. The performance is broken up over 4 acts and three days, and it is up to you to solve the crime!
Included in this package:
Murder Mystery Weekend at The Pridwin
Breakfast at your leisure is included with your stay.
Congress Hall
Available Friday, November 3 through Sunday, November 5, 2023
It’s 1890. You’ve taken your seat to dine at Congress Hall for an elegant evening by the sea. Your esteemed company includes President Benjamin Harrison and his fiancee Mary Lord Dimmick, artist Edmond Darch Lewis, hotelier Rose Halpin and professor Percey Longfellow. . .
read moreThe night is divine as the stars shine over the Atlantic, and all is well—that is, until Cape May Star and Wave columnist Katherine Kerry observes much more than merriment and gaiety: a murder at America’s First Seaside Resort... and it’s up to you to crack the case!
Spend a two-night stay with us and watch the mystery unfold as you experience three days filled with riddles, clues and a whodunit that will keep you guessing until the very end. From costumes and storylines to humor and problem solving, our partners at Murder Cafe will be sure to entertain and surprise guests. The performance is broken up over 4 acts and three days, and it is up to you to solve the crime!
Included in this package: