Rooms & Cottages

At the Pridwin

The Pridwin’s accommodations provide true Shelter Island luxury. Inside our historic hotel, each guest room features nautical accents throughout—a nod to the Pridwin’s location perched on a rise overlooking Crescent Beach. For guests looking for a little more elbow room, The Pridwin Cottages offer a spacious and private stay, complete with private decks, living areas and gas fireplaces.

Select Your Accommodations:


Hillside Room

One King Bed

215 ft²

Equal parts cozy and classic, our sunny south-facing Hillside Rooms feature one King bed and views of the greenery and cottages nestled around the Pridwin grounds.

Book Now View Floorplans
pridwin waterview room

Waterview Room

One King Bed

215 ft²

Our Waterview Rooms feature one plush King-size bed and breathtaking views of Crescent Beach. Take in a sunset over Long Island Sound—all from the comfort of your guestroom.

Book Now View Floorplans
floor plan of Pridwin guest accommodations

Corner Preferred Room

One King Bed | Queen Sleeper Sofa

230 ft²

Spacious and filled with natural light, our Corner Preferred Rooms feature windows on two sides of the guest room, enabling gorgeous water views of Crescent Beach and Long Island sound. Each Corner Preferred Room is furnished with one King-size bed, as well as a Queen sleeper sofa.

Book Now View Floorplans

Terrace Room

One King Bed | Queen Sleeper Sofa

230 ft²

Located on the ground floor of the hotel, our spacious Terrace rooms feature an outdoor deck with breathtaking views of Crescent Beach. Each Terrace room is furnished with one King-size bed, as well as a Queen sleeper sofa.

Book Now View Floorplans

Birch Cottage

Studio-Style Cottages | One Bedroom | Dog Friendly

529 ft² (interior and deck)

Quaint and well-appointed, our Birch Cottages offer private pet-friendly studio-style accommodations. Each Birch Cottage features a kitchenette, a Full-size sleeper sofa, a gas fireplace and a private deck overlooking Crescent Beach.

Book Now View Floorplans

Hickory Cottage

Studio-Style Cottages | One Bedroom

620 ft² (interior and deck)

Our Hickory Cottages offer private studio-style accommodations with excellent water views overlooking Crescent Beach. Each Hickory Cottage features a kitchenette, a Full-size sleeper sofa, a gas fireplace and a private deck.

Book Now View Floorplans
floor plan of Pridwin guest accommodations

Larch Cottage

Studio-Style Cottages | One Bedroom

645 ft² (interior and deck)

Our Larch Cottages are perfect for families and groups looking for more space to relax. Each Larch Cottage features a bedroom with a King-size bed, a separate living room with a Full-size sleeper sofa, a kitchenette, a gas fireplace and a private deck with partial water views overlooking Crescent Beach.

Book Now View Floorplans
floor plan of Pridwin guest accommodations

Red Oak Cottage

Studio-Style Cottages | One Bedroom

860 ft² (interior and deck)

Our Red Oak cottages sport excellent water views overlooking Crescent Beach and Shelter Island Sound. Each Red Oak Cottage features a bedroom with a King-size bed, a separate living room with a Full-size sleeper sofa, a kitchenette, a gas fireplace and a private deck.

Book Now View Floorplans
White Oak Cottage living room at the PridwinWhite Oak Cottage living room at the Pridwin

White Oak Cottage

Lofted Cottages | Two Bedrooms

1120 ft² (interior and deck)

Spacious and well-appointed, our White Oak cottages feature living rooms with double-height ceilings, a bedroom with King bed, a Full-size sleeper sofa, a lofted second-floor bedroom and bathroom, a kitchenette, a gas fireplace and a private deck overlooking Crescent Beach.

Book Now View Floorplans
floor plan of Pridwin guest accommodations

Caroline Cottage

Multi-Room House | One Bedroom

930 ft² (interior and deck)

Private and secluded, The Caroline Cottage offers private house-style accommodations and views overlooking a wooded grove of trees. The Caroline Cottage features bedroom with a King-size bed, a separate living room with a Full-size sleeper sofa, a gas fireplace and a kitchenette with an apartment-size refrigerator.

Book Now
floor plan of Pridwin guest accommodations

Fraser Cottage

Multi-Room House | Two Bedrooms

1289 ft² (interior and deck)

Nestled amongst a wooded grove of trees, the Fraser Cottage offers private house-style accommodations. This two-bedroom, two-bathroom cottage features a kitchenette with an apartment-size refrigerator, spacious living accommodations and a gas fireplace.

Book Now

Hillside Room

One King Bed

215 ft²

Equal parts cozy and classic, our sunny south-facing Hillside Rooms feature one King bed and views of the greenery and cottages nestled around the Pridwin grounds.

Book Now View Floorplans
pridwin waterview room

Waterview Room

One King Bed

215 ft²

Our Waterview Rooms feature one plush King-size bed and breathtaking views of Crescent Beach. Take in a sunset over Long Island Sound—all from the comfort of your guestroom.

Book Now View Floorplans
floor plan of Pridwin guest accommodations

Corner Preferred Room

One King Bed | Queen Sleeper Sofa

230 ft²

Spacious and filled with natural light, our Corner Preferred Rooms feature windows on two sides of the guest room, enabling gorgeous water views of Crescent Beach and Long Island sound. Each Corner Preferred Room is furnished with one King-size bed, as well as a Queen sleeper sofa.

Book Now View Floorplans

Terrace Room

One King Bed | Queen Sleeper Sofa

230 ft²

Located on the ground floor of the hotel, our spacious Terrace rooms feature an outdoor deck with breathtaking views of Crescent Beach. Each Terrace room is furnished with one King-size bed, as well as a Queen sleeper sofa.

Book Now View Floorplans

Birch Cottage

Studio-Style Cottages | One Bedroom | Dog Friendly

529 ft² (interior and deck)

Quaint and well-appointed, our Birch Cottages offer private pet-friendly studio-style accommodations. Each Birch Cottage features a kitchenette, a Full-size sleeper sofa, a gas fireplace and a private deck overlooking Crescent Beach.

Book Now View Floorplans

Hickory Cottage

Studio-Style Cottages | One Bedroom

620 ft² (interior and deck)

Our Hickory Cottages offer private studio-style accommodations with excellent water views overlooking Crescent Beach. Each Hickory Cottage features a kitchenette, a Full-size sleeper sofa, a gas fireplace and a private deck.

Book Now View Floorplans
floor plan of Pridwin guest accommodations

Larch Cottage

Studio-Style Cottages | One Bedroom

645 ft² (interior and deck)

Our Larch Cottages are perfect for families and groups looking for more space to relax. Each Larch Cottage features a bedroom with a King-size bed, a separate living room with a Full-size sleeper sofa, a kitchenette, a gas fireplace and a private deck with partial water views overlooking Crescent Beach.

Book Now View Floorplans
floor plan of Pridwin guest accommodations

Red Oak Cottage

Studio-Style Cottages | One Bedroom

860 ft² (interior and deck)

Our Red Oak cottages sport excellent water views overlooking Crescent Beach and Shelter Island Sound. Each Red Oak Cottage features a bedroom with a King-size bed, a separate living room with a Full-size sleeper sofa, a kitchenette, a gas fireplace and a private deck.

Book Now View Floorplans
White Oak Cottage living room at the PridwinWhite Oak Cottage living room at the Pridwin

White Oak Cottage

Lofted Cottages | Two Bedrooms

1120 ft² (interior and deck)

Spacious and well-appointed, our White Oak cottages feature living rooms with double-height ceilings, a bedroom with King bed, a Full-size sleeper sofa, a lofted second-floor bedroom and bathroom, a kitchenette, a gas fireplace and a private deck overlooking Crescent Beach.

Book Now View Floorplans
floor plan of Pridwin guest accommodations

Fraser Cottage

Multi-Room House | Two Bedrooms

1289 ft² (interior and deck)

Nestled amongst a wooded grove of trees, the Fraser Cottage offers private house-style accommodations. This two-bedroom, two-bathroom cottage features a kitchenette with an apartment-size refrigerator, spacious living accommodations and a gas fireplace.

Book Now
floor plan of Pridwin guest accommodations

Caroline Cottage

Multi-Room House | One Bedroom

930 ft² (interior and deck)

Private and secluded, The Caroline Cottage offers private house-style accommodations and views overlooking a wooded grove of trees. The Caroline Cottage features bedroom with a King-size bed, a separate living room with a Full-size sleeper sofa, a gas fireplace and a kitchenette with an apartment-size refrigerator.

Book Now

A Message from The Pridwin

Re-opening April 2023

We would like to thank everyone who visited The Pridwin Hotel and Cottages for making our reopening such a success. After an incredible 2022 season and celebrating our ”first” Thanksgiving Holiday at the hotel in its 95 year history we have decided to shorten our season this year by 5 weeks so we can prepare for the 2023 season ahead. With our late opening this summer due to supply chain issues and other delays we have a long list of projects to finish before we reopen next Spring
We want to thank all of our guests, the Shelter Island Community, and everyone in our Pridwin family who contributed to making our first year so memorable and look forward to seeing you at our reopening in late March and extending our season next year through New Years Eve 2024, a long held goal of the Petry’s and Cape Resorts.

Many thanks and we will see you next Spring,
Curtis Bashaw and Glenn Petry
guest room at the Pridwin

Stay
Overnight

Book Your Stay

Group
Retreats

Learn More

it’s easy to find us

Shelter Island is easily accessible by car ferry. The North Ferry departs from Greenport, NY and the South Ferry from North Haven, NY.


FERRY SERVICE:

Ferry service to Shelter Island is available from both the North Fork via Greenport and the South Fork via Sag Harbor. There are no reservations. Traffic is boarded on a first-come, first-serve basis. Cars and bicycles pay on board. Both ferries are cash only. For ferry schedules, visit NorthFerry.com and SouthFerry.com.


DIRECTIONS FROM THE SOUTH FORK:

Take the Long Island Expressway (I-495) to Sunrise Highway. Sunrise Highway (Route 27) turns into County Road 39. North onto Sandy Hollow Road (Exit 8) to North Sea Road. Then to Noyac Road; left at traffic circle onto Long Beach Road (turns into Route 114 at traffic circle). Take Route 114 to South Ferry.

DIRECTIONS FROM THE NORTH FORK:

Take the Long Island Expressway to end. Continue straight (Route 58). Follow signs to Greenport (Route 25). Once in Greenport, look for signs to North Ferry or Route 114.


Valet Parking is provided. Please pull up in front of the hotel and an attendant will assist you with your luggage and car.

From Google Maps:

View Google Map & Enter Your Starting Point

press & media inquiries:

[email protected]