A Plate Of Food — Elevated takes on beloved
Long Island fare
Discover More

Fresh Long Island Flavor

Name: The Restaurant at Baron's Cove
Address: 31 W. Water Street, Sag Harbor, NY, 11963, US
Telephone: (631) 725-2100
Price range: $$$

The Restaurant at Baron’s Cove is a classic All-American dining room offering elevated takes on beloved Long Island fare.

Reserve a Table

Call: (631) 725-2100

HOURS

Open Daily

BREAKFAST
Daily 7:30am - 11:30am

BRUNCH
Saturday & Sunday 11:30am - 3:30pm

LUNCH
Daily 11:30am - 2:30pm

DINNER
Friday & Saturday 5:00pm - 10:00pm
Sunday - Thursday 5:00pm - 9:30pm

View Menus Reserve a Table

Honored by Wine Spectator

2025 Award of Excellence

The Restaurant at Baron’s Cove was honored by Wine Spectator with a 2025 Award of Excellence. Our “by the glass” selection changes in concert with Chef Zackary’s seasonal fare, so that together we can highlight ingredients from our local Long Island farms and the bountiful waters that surround us.

View the Wine List

Our Menus

Reserve a Table

Menus

Dining

Rooted in local connection, our award-winning Restaurant sources vegetables, fish, and meats from a variety of farmers and artisans across the East End and beyond.

Eggs & Omelettes

Just Here For Breakfast25.00

Two eggs cooked any way, choice of meat, home fries, toast

Eggs Benedict26.00

poached eggs, canadian bacon, hollandaise, english muffin, home fries

{add smoked salmon +15, lobster +21}

Breakfast Sandwich18.00

two eggs any-style, cheddar cheese, choice of meat, home fries

Florentine Omelette21.00

goat cheese, fresh spinach, blistered tomatoes, home fries, toast

Western Omelette21.00

onions, red bell peppers, ham, cheddar cheese, home fries, toast

Sunrise Staples

Housemade Belgian Waffle20.00

berry compote, whipped cream, powdered sugar

{add chocolate chips +3, blueberries +3, banana +3}

Housemade Pancakes20.00

berry compote, whipped cream, powdered sugar

{add chocolate chips +3, blueberries +3, banana +3}

Sourdough Avocado Toast19.00

heirloom tomatoes, whipped ricotta, chives, toasted sesame seeds, e.v.o.o., sea salt
{add egg +4}

Steel Cut Oatmeal14.00

brown sugar, fresh berries, candied walnuts

Yogurt Parfait15.00

granola, honey, bananas, berries

NYC Deli Platter26.00

lox, scallion cream cheese, tomato, red onion, cucumber, capers, plain bagel

Sides

Libations

Smoothies

Juices

Coffee & Tea

Starters

Pastry Basket23.00

banana bread, seasonal scones, croissants

East Hampton Oysters*24/48

rice-cucumber mignonette, cocktail sauce, lemon

Jumbo Shrimp Cocktail24.00

old bay aioli, cocktail sauce, lemon

Jonah Crab Claws32.00

ponzu vinaigrette, cocktail sauce, lemon

Seafood Plateau*110.00

oysters, shrimp cocktail, jonah crab, tuna tartare, accoutrements

Baron's Plateau170.00

clams, oysters, shrimp cocktail, jonah crab, tuna tartare, lobster, accoutrements

Tuna Tartare28.00

red berry coulis, umami glaze, whipped avocado, yuzu pickled radish, tapioca crisps

Gazpacho15.00

tomatoes, cucumber, red bell peppers, onion, garlic, green chile

Caesar Salad*17.00

baby gem lettuce, charred radicchio, anchovy, parmesan, garlic-herb bread crumbs

{add chicken +8, shrimp +16, lobster +21}

Bibb Lettuce18.00

roasted beets, candied walnuts, whipped chèvre, balsamic vinaigrette

{add chicken +8, shrimp +16, lobster +21}

Sourdough Avocado Toast19.00

heirloom tomatoes, whipped ricotta, chives, toasted sesame seeds, e.v.o.o., sea salt

{add egg +4}

Crispy Calamari22.00

preserved lemon, calabrian chiles, wild ramp emulsion

Roasted Cauliflower18.00

lemongrass avocado mousse, chili sauce, thai basil

Buratta18.00

sun-dried tomato jam, white balsamic reduction, basil, bruschetta

Bouillabaisse26.00

lobster-tomato broth, montauk red prawns, mussels, catch of the day

Mains

Lobster Roll45.00

old bay aioli, french fries, housemade pickle, simple salad

Steak Frites*45.00

8 oz. hanger steak, simple salad, french fries

Eggs Benedict*26.00

poached eggs, canadian bacon, hollandaise, english muffin, home fries, smoked salmon

{add smoked salmon +15, lobster +21}

Catch of the DayMP

risotto, roasted carrots, flame badger beets, beurre blanc

8oz Dry Aged Angus Burger*29.00

cheddar cheese, chipotle aioli, lettuce, tomato, onion, housemade pickle, brioche bun

{add bacon +4, avocado +5, egg +4}

Chicken & Waffle26.00

maple-jalapeño glaze, vanilla bourbon mousse, sautéed greens

Florentine Omelette21.00

goat cheese, fresh spinach, blistered tomatoes, home fries, toast

Sides

Libations

Smoothies & Juicies

Coffee & Tea

Appetizers

East Hampton Oysters*24/48

rice-cucumber mignonette, fermented fresno chile, lemon

Jumbo Shrimp Cocktail24.00

old bay aioli, cocktail sauce, lemon

Jonah Crab Claws32.00

ponzu vinaigrette, cocktail sauce, lemon

Seafood Plateau*110.00

oysters, shrimp cocktail, jonah crab, tuna tartare, accoutrements

Baron's Plateau*170.00

clams, lobster, oysters, shrimp cocktail, jonah crab, tuna tartare, accoutrements

Caesar Salad18.00

baby gem lettuce, radicchio, anchovy, parmesan, garlic-herb bread crumbs

Bibb Lettuce Salad18.00

marinated cucumbers, pickled shallots, heirloom tomatoes, green chile vinaigrette

{add chicken +8, shrimp +16, lobster +21}

Gazpacho15.00

local tomatoes, english cucumber, red bell peppers, onion, garlic, green chile

Crispy Calamari22.00

preserved lemon, basil, calabrian chile, wild ramp emulsion

Tempura Cauliflower18.00

lemongrass avocado mousse, chili sauce, thai basil

Tuna Tartare*28.00

red berry coulis, umami gelee, whipped avocado, yuzu pickled radish, tapioca crisps

Entrées

Lobster Roll45.00

old bay aioli, french fries, simple salad, housemade pickle

8oz Dry Aged Angus Burger*29.00

cheddar cheese, chipotle aioli, lettuce, tomato, onion, housemade pickle, french fries

{add bacon +4, avocado +5, egg +4}

Crispy Chicken Sandwich24.00

nashville sauce, housemade dill pickles, brioche, french fries

Ancient Grain Bowl18.00

wheatberries, quinoa, roasted corn, cherry tomato, toasted almonds, green chile

Fish & Chips38.00

beer battered catch of the day, house-cut steak fries, paprika crema, osetra platinum caviar

Steak Frites45.00

8oz hanger steak, french fries, bearnaise, simple salad

Raw Bar

East Hampton Oysters*24/48

rice-cucumber mignonette, fermented fresno chile, lemon

Jumbo Shrimp Cocktail24.00

old bay aioli, cocktail sauce, lemon

Jonah Crab Claws32.00

ponzu vinaigrette, cocktail sauce, lemon

Seafood Plateau*110.00

oysters, shrimp cocktail, jonah crab, tuna tartare, accoutrements

Baron's Plateau*170.00

clams, oysters, shrimp cocktail, jonah crab, tuna tartare, lobster, accoutrements,

Long Island Littleneck Clams*18/36

cocktail sauce, fermented fresno chile, lemon

Soup & Salads

Appetizers

Mussels19.00

spiced calabrian broth, chive oil, parsley, sourdough

Buratta19.00

sun-dried tomato jam, white balsamic reduction, basil, bruschetta

Beef Tartare*24.00

smoked onion aioli, capers, shallots, cornichons, parmesan espuma, cured egg yolk, rye crisps

Crispy Calamari22.00

preserved lemon, calabrian chiles, wild ramp emulsion

Tempura Cauliflower18.00

lemongrass avocado mousse, chile sauce, thai basillemongrass basil

Duck Leg Confit21.00

quince, foie gras mousse, pistachio crumble

Entrées

Pan Seared Local Halibut49.00

confit fennel, sautéed spinach, zucchini, blood orange reduction

8 Oz. Prime Filet Mignon*65.00

pommes dauphinoise, braised leeks, roasted red pepper chutney, sunchokes, bordelaise

Roasted Half Chicken42.00

wheatberries, pattypan squash, pickled fresno chiles, salsa verde

Lobster Roll45.00

old bay aioli, french fries, simple salad, housemade pickle

Braised Short Rib49.00

pommes purée, cipollini onions, gremolata, crispy shallots, sauce perigord

8oz Dry Aged Angus Burger*29.00

cheddar cheese, chipotle aioli, lettuce, tomato, red onion, housemade pickle, french fries

{add bacon +4, avocado +5, egg+4}

Rigatoni Calabrese32.00

roasted red peppers, calabrian chiles, cherry tomatoes, ricotta, pecorino, basil, e.v.o.o.

{add chicken +8, shrimp +16, lobster +21}

Lions Mane Mushroom Steak39.00

roasted bell pepper, celery root mousse, leeks, lemon-garlic agrodulce

Catch of the DayMP

risotto, roasted carrots, flame badger beets, beurre blanc

Pan-Roasted Long Island Duck Breast44.00

white asparagus, brown beech mushrooms, cherry gastrique, summer truffle

Lobster Bucatini45.00

calabrian chile, roasted garlic, shallots, lemon, white wine butter sauce, herb breadcrumbs

Sides

Dessert

Baron's Sundae18.00

caramelized bananas, vanilla & chocolate gelato, chocolate sauce, caramel sauce, rainbow sprinkles, candied walnuts

Caramelized Cheesecake15.00

mint, creme anglaise

Lava Cake15.00

vanilla gelato, whipped cream

Cookies & Milk15.00

two warm chocolate chip cookies & vanilla milk

Chocolate Pot De Crème15.00

vanilla crème fraîche sugar crust, fresh berries

"Tiramichoux"15.00

pate a choux, whipped vanilla marscapone, cocoa powder, espresso craquelin

House Made Gelato & Sorbet

vanilla, chocolate & rotating sorbet flavors

(two scoops 10 / one scoop 5)

Coffee Drinks

Dessert Martinis

Ports & Dessert Wine

Youthful at Heart Menu

Mac & Cheese14.00

cavatappi, 3 cheese sauce (cheddar, american, asiago), toasted breadcrumbs

Grilled Cheese14.00

cheddar cheese + choice of french fries or fruit cup

Crudite14.00

choice of hummus or ranch dressing with celery, cucumber, carrots

Peanut Butter & Jelly14.00

served with french fries or fruit cup

Burger Sliders14.00

american cheese + choice of french fries or fruit cup

Chicken Tenders14.00

served with french fries or fruit cup

Side Kale Salad9.00

tomatoes, cucumbers, kale with ranch dressing

Fruit Cup9.00

sliced fruit & berries

Dining Specials

AVAILABLE DURING DINNER SERVICE

Dinner & a Movie with Sag Harbor Cinema

Pair an evening of fine entertainment at Sag Harbor Cinema with a delicious dinner at Baron's Cove and enjoy 15% off your total check!

Learn More

AVAILABLE WITH VALID MILITARY ID

Military Discount

Bring family & friends to The Restaurant at Baron's Cove for a memorable evening. Enjoy a 15% discount for your entire party seated at the table.

Must present a Valid Military ID in order to receive the discount. Discount is applicable to food items only. Not Valid with other offers or discounts.

Restaurant Photo Gallery

A Table With Food And Drinks On It On A Deck

Let's Be Social

@baronscove

Email [email protected] Call (844) 227-6672

Request Information

For all inquiries for meeting rooms, weddings or events over 10 persons, please fill out the form below.

Search

Most Frequent Searches

Stay Dates & Guests

Fresh Long Island Flavor

Open Daily

2025 Award of Excellence

Our Menus

Dining

Eggs & Omelettes

Just Here For Breakfast25.00

Eggs Benedict26.00

Breakfast Sandwich18.00

Florentine Omelette21.00

Western Omelette21.00

Sunrise Staples

Housemade Belgian Waffle20.00

Housemade Pancakes20.00

Sourdough Avocado Toast19.00

Steel Cut Oatmeal14.00

Yogurt Parfait15.00

NYC Deli Platter26.00

Sides

Fruit Cup10.00

Thick Cut Bacon10.00

Turkey Bacon6.00

Sausage Links6.00

Home Fries8.00

Sliced Avocado6.00

Plain Bagel & Cream Cheese8.00

Toast4.00

Libations

Bloody Mary18.00

Mimosa17.00

Bellini17.00

Smoothies

Fresh Berry13.00

Orange & Ginger13.00

Juices

Orange6.00

Grapefruit6.00

Cranberry6.00

Tomato6.00

Apple6.00

Pineapple6.00

Lemonade6.00

Coffee & Tea

La Colombe Coffee4.00

La Colombe Iced Coffee6.00

Espresso5.00

Double Espresso7.00

Cappuccino6.00

Iced Tea6.00

Harney & Sons Tea4.00

Starters

Pastry Basket23.00

East Hampton Oysters*24/48

Jumbo Shrimp Cocktail24.00

Jonah Crab Claws32.00

Seafood Plateau*110.00

Baron's Plateau170.00

Tuna Tartare28.00

Gazpacho15.00

Caesar Salad*17.00

Bibb Lettuce18.00

Sourdough Avocado Toast19.00

Crispy Calamari22.00

Roasted Cauliflower18.00

Buratta18.00

Bouillabaisse26.00

Mains

Lobster Roll45.00

Steak Frites*45.00

Eggs Benedict*26.00

Catch of the DayMP

8oz Dry Aged Angus Burger*29.00

Chicken & Waffle26.00

Florentine Omelette21.00

Sides

Fruit Cup10.00

Thick Cut Bacon10.00