Reopening on Friday, March 29
The Rusty Nail will reopen for the season on Friday, March 29!
Be sure to follow us on Instagram @RustyNailCapeMay, where we'll post throughout the offseason about exciting property updates and improvements.
View Cape May Restaurants
Rusty Nail Menus
Eggs*
all eggs come with homefries and a choice of toast (white, wheat, rye)
substitute fresh fruit for homefries.....4
substitute bagel, english muffin or biscuit.....2
TWO EGGS ANY STYLE8
add applewood bacon, ham, or sausage 4.50
EGGS "THE NAIL"23
poached on top of a 4oz crab cake on an english muffin, old bay hollandaise sauce
OMELETS*
prepared with 3 eggs, home fries and a choice of toast (white, wheat, rye)
substitute fresh fruit for homefries.....4
substitute bagel, english muffin or biscuit.....2
BEACH PLUM FARM OMELET13
onion, tomatoes, spinach, mushrooms
MEDITERRANEAN OMELET13
spinach, tomatoes, feta
WESTERN OMELET13
peppers, onions, ham
HAM OMELET, BACON OMELET, SAUSAGE OMELET12
RUSTY NAIL MEAT LOVER’S OMELET14
ham, bacon and sausage
PANCAKES & FRENCH TOAST*
comes with maple syrup and butter
add blueberries, chocolate chips, or banana 2
add Beach Plum Farm berries & whipped cream 3
SHORT STACK (2)7
PLAIN PANCAKES (3)11
SHORT STACK FRENCH TOAST (2)7
PLAIN FRENCH TOAST (3)11
PLATES*
BREAKFAST BURRITO14
scrambled egg, ham, black beans, pico de gallo, home fries, choice of cheese (american, swiss, provolone, pepper jack, cooper sharp, cheddar)
EGG & CHEESE10
on choice of bagel, biscuit, or English Muffin
add choice of meat (ham, bacon or sausage) $2.50 each
CHEF JIMMY’S OWN CREAMED CHIPPED BEEF14
on toast, home fries
JUST FOR KIDS10
choice of cereal & milk, eggs any style with home fries & toast, mini pancakes, french toast sticks, beverage included, served on our Beach Shack frisbee
SIDES*
TOAST2
ENGLISH MUFFIN3
BAGEL4.50
with cream cheese
BISCUIT3
CORNBREAD4.50
with honey
BREAKFAST MEATS4.50
applewood bacon, ham or sausage
HOME FRIES4
CEREAL OR GRANOLA & MILK3.50
FRESH FRUIT BOWL9
YOGURT PARFAIT10
granola, fresh fruit
*Menu prices and menu items are subject to change without prior notice.
SOUPS & SALADS*
add to any salad: grilled chicken 8, salmon 12, shrimp 14, crab cake 19
NEW ENGLAND CLAM CHOWDER12
light and creamy, clams, celery, onion garlic, potatoes, oyster crackers
CAESAR SALAD14
romaine lettuce, croutons, parmesan cheese, creamy caesar dressing
FARM HOUSE SALAD13
seasonal leafy greens, vegetables from our farm, strawberry vinaigrette
COBB SALAD16
crumbled bacon, tomatoes, avocado, egg, blue cheese
APPS*
SALSA & CHIPS9
CLAMS CASINO15
stuffed with bacon, onions, peppers, melted cooper cheese
PEEL & EAT SHRIMP22
old bay and shrimp broth
SHRIMP COCKTAIL19
served with cocktail sauce & lemon
STRAWBERRY HOT WINGS19
beach plum farm fresh strawberry dipping sauce
CHICKEN WINGS19
homemade hot or bbq sauce, blue cheese or ranch dressing
FRIED CLAM STRIPS16
tartar sauce
FRIED MOZZARELLA BITES12
marinara sauce
5 DEEP FRIED MAC-N-CHEESE BALLS13
horseradish dipping sauce
JIMMY'S HOMEMADE TEMPURA STYLE ZUCCHINI STICKS12
marinara or chipotle mayo
NACHOS
NAIL SIGNATURE12
homemade cheddar cheese sauce, pico de gallo, pickled jalapeño, queso fresco, avocado crema, guacamole
BUFFALO CHICKEN16
homemade cheddar cheese sauce, grilled chicken, queso fresco, ranch, scallions
PULLED PORK15
homemade cheddar cheese sauce, beach plum farm pulled pork, bbq drizzle, scallions
SANDWICHES*
all sandwiches & wraps served with chips & a pickle OR a side salad
THE NAIL BURGER19
LTO, choice of cheese (cheddar, american, provolone, cooper sharp, blue cheese or spicy pepper jack)
add choice of bacon, mushrooms or fried onions 2
JERSEY-STYLE LOBSTER ROLL32
fresh lobster salad on a fresh-baked roll, with green leaf lettuce & tomato
FRIED LOCAL FLOUNDER23
LTO, coleslaw, tartar sauce
CRAB CAKE27
LTO, broiled or fried, tartar sauce, coleslaw
BEACH PLUM FARM PULLED PORK18
fresh-smoked roast pork, house-made bbq sauce, coleslaw
BEACH SHACK CLUB16
all natural apple wood smoked turkey and bacon, romaine lettuce, tomato, mayo
GRILLED CHICKEN17
LTO, choice of cheese (cheddar, american, provolone, cooper sharp, blue cheese, spicy pepper jack)
add choice of bacon, mushrooms, fried onions +2 each
CHICKEN QUESADILLA15
cheddar cheese, onion, red and green peppers
WRAPS*
substitute gluten free wrap +2.50
STEAK24
cheddar cheese, pico de gallo, lettuce, chipotle mayo, served with a side of guacamole and sour cream
THE NAIL24
fried fish, cheddar cheese, pico de gallo,
lettuce, chipotle mayo
served with a side of guacamole & sour cream
GRILLED VEGETABLE15
grilled onion, red pepper, yellow squash, zucchini, portobello mushroom, eggplant, provolone cheese
CHICKEN SALAD16
cranberries, lettuce, tomato
Tacos*
(2) served complete on flour tortillas
gluten free option with corn tortillas
BAJA GRILLED FISH25
grilled mahi, fresh corn, pico de gallo, lettuce, cheddar cheese, black beans, guacamole, coleslaw
GRILLED CHICKEN20
grilled chicken, fresh corn, pico de gallo, lettuce, cheddar cheese, black beans, guacamole
SHRIMP26
grilled shrimp, fresh corn, pico de gallo, lettuce, cheddar cheese, black beans, guacamole
SIDES*
HOUSE-MADE COLESLAW4
1/2 FARM HOUSE SALAD5
BAKED MAC & CHEESE6
FRIES
FRENCH FRIES9
RUSTY NAIL FRIES10
BAKED MAC & CHEESE6
FRIES
FRENCH FRIES9
RUSTY NAIL FRIES10
RUSTY NAIL FRIES10
old bay seasoning
LOADED FRIES14
cheese, bacon, scallions, side of sour cream
*Menu prices and menu items are subject to change without prior notice.
SOUPS & SALADS*
add to any salad:
grilled chicken 8, salmon 12, shrimp 14, crab cake 19
NEW ENGLAND CLAM CHOWDER12
light and creamy, clams, celery, onion garlic, potatoes, oyster crackers
CAESAR SALAD14
romaine lettuce, croutons, parmesan cheese, creamy caesar dressing
FARM HOUSE SALAD13
seasonal leafy greens, vegetables from our farm, strawberry vinaigrette
COBB SALAD16
crumbled bacon, tomatoes, avocado, egg, blue cheese
APPS*
SALSA & CHIPS9
CLAMS CASINO15
stuffed with bacon, onions, peppers, melted cooper cheese
PEEL & EAT SHRIMP22
old bay and shrimp broth
SHRIMP COCKTAIL19
served with cocktail sauce & lemon
STRAWBERRY HOT WINGS19
beach plum farm fresh strawberry dipping sauce
CHICKEN WINGS19
homemade hot or bbq sauce, blue cheese or ranch dressing
FRIED CLAM STRIPS16
tartar sauce
FRIED MOZZARELLA BITES12
marinara sauce
DEEP FRIED MAC-N-CHEESE BALLS13
horseradish dipping sauce
JIMMY'S HOMEMADE TEMPURA STYLE ZUCCHINI STICKS12
marinara or chipotle mayo
NACHOS
NAIL SIGNATURE12
homemade cheddar cheese sauce, pico de gallo, pickled jalapeño, queso fresco, avocado crema, guacamole
BUFFALO CHICKEN16
homemade cheddar cheese sauce, grilled chicken, queso fresco, ranch, scallions
PULLED PORK15
homemade cheddar cheese sauce, beach plum farm pulled pork, bbq drizzle, scallions
FRIES
FRENCH FRIES9
RUSTY NAIL FRIES10
old bay seasoning
LOADED FRIES14
cheese, bacon, scallions, side of sour cream
SANDWICHES*
all sandwiches & wraps served with chips & a pickle OR a side salad
THE NAIL BURGER19
LTO, choice of cheese (cheddar, american, provolone, cooper sharp, blue cheese, spicy pepper jack)
add choice of bacon, mushrooms or fried onions +2 each
FRIED LOCAL FLOUNDER23
LTO, coleslaw, tartar sauce
CRAB CAKE27
LTO, broiled or fried, tartar sauce, coleslaw
BEACH PLUM FARM PULLED PORK18
fresh-smoked roast pork, house-made bbq sauce, coleslaw
JERSEY-STYLE LOBSTER ROLL32
fresh lobster salad on a fresh-baked roll, with green leaf lettuce and tomato
GRILLED CHICKEN17
LTO, choice of cheese (cheddar, american, provolone, cooper sharp, blue cheese, spicy pepper jack)
add choice of bacon, mushrooms or fired onions 2
WRAPS
THE NAIL24
fried local fish, cheddar cheese, pico de gallo, lettuce, chipotle mayo, served with a side of guacamole and sour cream
GRILLED VEGETABLE15
grilled onion, red pepper, yellow squash, zucchini, portobello mushroom, eggplant, provolone cheese
TACOS*
(2) served complete on flour tortillas
gluten free option with corn tortillas
BAJA GRILLED FISH25
grilled mahi, fresh corn, pico de gallo, lettuce, cheddar cheese, black beans, guacamole, coleslaw
GRILLED CHICKEN20
grilled chicken, fresh corn, pico de gallo, lettuce, cheddar cheese, black beans, guacamole
SHRIMP26
grilled shrimp, fresh corn, pico de gallo, lettuce, cheddar cheese, black beans, guacamole
MAINS*
Select two: cheddar mashed potatoes, baked potato, french fries, baked yam, baked mac & cheese, seasonal vegetable selection, side salad
FRIED OR BROILED FLOUNDER32
GRILLED SALMON31
CRAB-STUFFED FLOUNDER36
FRIED SHRIMP34
JUMBO LUMP CRAB CAKES (2)44
broiled or fried
BBQ RIBS26
1/2 rack, served with cornbread, coleslaw
add bbq shrimp +14
PASTA
served complete
SEAFOOD FRA DIAVOLO32
jumbo shrimp, jumbo crebmeat, fra diavolo sauce, angel hair pasta
PASTA A LA VODKA21
bowtie pasta, fresh vegetables, vodka cream sauce
add grilled chicken 8
add salmon 12
add shrimp 14
add jumbo lump crabmeat 19
CHICKEN PARMESAN26
angel hair pasta
SIDES*
HOUSE-MADE COLESLAW 4
1/2 FARM HOUSE SALAD 5
VEGETABLE OF THE DAY 4
CHEDDAR MASHED POTATOS 6
BAKED POTATO 5
BAKED YAM 5
PASTA WITH RED SAUCE 5
CORN BREAD 5
*Menu prices and menu items are subject to change without prior notice.
SPECIALTY COCKTAILS*
THE NAIL CRUSH13
vodka, fresh orange or grapefruit, orange liqueur, club
BLACKBERRY SMASH13
bourbon, fresh blackberry, lemon, mint, club
INDIGO MULE14
empress 1908 gin, fresh lime, ginger beer
BEACHCOMBER13
spiced & white rum aperol, grapefruit, lime
PALOMA12
blanco tequila, orange liqueur, grapefruit, salted rim
SHACK MARGARITA12
blanco tequila, orange liqueur, lime
SMOKEHOUSE MARGARITA14
mezcal, orange liqueur, lime, pinot noir floater
JALAPEÑO MARGARITA15
jalapeño-infused tequila, orange liqueur, lime
FROZEN SANDY BEACH14
rusty nail's signature frozen drink featuring a blend of light, dark and coconut rum with tropical juices
WINE*
served 6oz, 9oz, or bottle
WHITE
SAUVIGNON BLANC, THE CROSSINGS12/16/48
New Zealand
CHARDONNAY, HAYES RANCH10/14/40
California
PINOT GRIGIO, SILVER GATE9/13/36
California
RED
PINOT NOIR, BALLARD CANYON10/14/40
California
CABERNET SAUVIGNON, MAN FAMILY11/15/42
South Africa
ROSÉ
WHISPERING ANGEL, THE BEACH12/16/48
France
SPARKLING
PROSECCO, AVISSI10/14/40
Italy
BEER*
coldest draft beer in Cape May as verified by Exit Zero magazine
ON TAP
VON C BREWING “WALKING ON CLOUDS”9
Hazy IPA - ABV 7% - IBU 12
SOUTHERN TIER BREWING CO. “PUMKING”9
Imperial Pumpkin Ale - ABV 8.6% - IBU 33
CAPE MAY BREWING CO. "CAPE MAY IPA"8
West Coast IPA - ABV 6.3% - IBU 34
CAPE MAY BREWING CO. “OKTOBERFEST”8
Marzen-Style Lager - ABV 5.8% - IBU 25
KONA BREWING “BIG WAVE”8
Golden Ale - ABV 4.4% - IBU 21
WEIHENSTEPHAN “HEFE-WEISSBBIER”8
Bavarian Wheat Beer - ABV 5.4% - IBU 14
MCKENZIE'S BLACK CHERRY HARD CIDER7
Cider - ABV 5% - IBU 8
MICHELOB ULTRA7
Lager - ABV 4.2% - IBU 10
BOTTLES & CANS
BUDWEISER6
COORS LIGHT6
MILLER LITE6
YUENGLING7
CORONA7
GUINNESS (PUB CANS)8
RED STRIPE7
HEINEKEN “00” (NON-ALCOHOLIC)6
HARD TEA / SODA / SELTZER
HOOP TEA6
SURFSIDE VODKA9
MILLER LITE6
YUENGLING7
CORONA7
GUINNESS (PUB CANS)8
RED STRIPE7
HEINEKEN “00” (NON-ALCOHOLIC)6
HARD TEA / SODA / SELTZER
HOOP TEA6
SURFSIDE VODKA9
CORONA7
GUINNESS (PUB CANS)8
RED STRIPE7
HEINEKEN “00” (NON-ALCOHOLIC)6
HARD TEA / SODA / SELTZER
HOOP TEA6
SURFSIDE VODKA9
RED STRIPE7
HEINEKEN “00” (NON-ALCOHOLIC)6
HARD TEA / SODA / SELTZER
HOOP TEA6
SURFSIDE VODKA9
HARD TEA / SODA / SELTZER
HOOP TEA6
SURFSIDE VODKA9
lemonade, or arnold palmer
CAPE MAY SPIRITS CO. BEACH BLENDS9
tropical vodka punch
NUTRL VODKA SODA8
orange or pineapple
KLYR RUM PUNCH8
fruit punch
WHITE CLAW7
black cherry
SPIRITS*
VODKA
WHEATLEY
ABSOLUT CITRON
ABSOLUT VANILLA
ABSOLUT RASPBERRI
TITO’S
STATESIDE
GREY GOOSE
GIN
BLUECOAT
TANQUERAY
HENDRICK’S
EMPRESS 1908
WHISKY
SEAGRAM’S 7
CROWN ROYAL
CROWN ROYAL REGAL APPLE
JAMESON
FIREBALL
RUM
BACARDI SUPERIORJOVEN
BACARDI COCONUT
CAPTAIN MORGAN SPICED
GOSLING’S BLACK SEAL
TEQUILA & MEZCAL
CORAZON BLANCO
TANTEO JALAPENO
CASAMIGOS BLANCO
PATRON SILVER
SOLENTO ORGANIC BLANCO
SOLENTO ORGANIC REPOSADO
SOLENTO ORGANIC ANEJO
DON JULIO 1942
ILEGAL MEZCAL JOVEN
BOURBON, RYE, TENNESSEE WHISKY
JIM BEAM
SAZERAC RYE
BUFFALO TRACE
JACK DANIELS
BULLEIT BOURBON
BULLEIT RYE
MAKER’S MARK
BLANTON’S SINGLE BARREL
SCOTCH
DEWAR’S
JOHNNIE WALKER BLACK
GLENLIVET 12 YR
ABSOLUT VANILLA
ABSOLUT RASPBERRI
TITO’S
STATESIDE
GREY GOOSE
GIN
BLUECOAT
TANQUERAY
HENDRICK’S
EMPRESS 1908
WHISKY
SEAGRAM’S 7
CROWN ROYAL
CROWN ROYAL REGAL APPLE
JAMESON
FIREBALL
RUM
BACARDI SUPERIORJOVEN
BACARDI COCONUT
CAPTAIN MORGAN SPICED
GOSLING’S BLACK SEAL
TEQUILA & MEZCAL
CORAZON BLANCO
TANTEO JALAPENO
CASAMIGOS BLANCO
PATRON SILVER
SOLENTO ORGANIC BLANCO
SOLENTO ORGANIC REPOSADO
SOLENTO ORGANIC ANEJO
DON JULIO 1942
ILEGAL MEZCAL JOVEN
BOURBON, RYE, TENNESSEE WHISKY
JIM BEAM
SAZERAC RYE
BUFFALO TRACE
JACK DANIELS
BULLEIT BOURBON
BULLEIT RYE
MAKER’S MARK
BLANTON’S SINGLE BARREL
SCOTCH
DEWAR’S
JOHNNIE WALKER BLACK
GLENLIVET 12 YR
TITO’S
STATESIDE
GREY GOOSE
GIN
BLUECOAT
TANQUERAY
HENDRICK’S
EMPRESS 1908
WHISKY
SEAGRAM’S 7
CROWN ROYAL
CROWN ROYAL REGAL APPLE
JAMESON
FIREBALL
RUM
BACARDI SUPERIORJOVEN
BACARDI COCONUT
CAPTAIN MORGAN SPICED
GOSLING’S BLACK SEAL
TEQUILA & MEZCAL
CORAZON BLANCO
TANTEO JALAPENO
CASAMIGOS BLANCO
PATRON SILVER
SOLENTO ORGANIC BLANCO
SOLENTO ORGANIC REPOSADO
SOLENTO ORGANIC ANEJO
DON JULIO 1942
ILEGAL MEZCAL JOVEN
BOURBON, RYE, TENNESSEE WHISKY
JIM BEAM
SAZERAC RYE
BUFFALO TRACE
JACK DANIELS
BULLEIT BOURBON
BULLEIT RYE
MAKER’S MARK
BLANTON’S SINGLE BARREL
SCOTCH
DEWAR’S
JOHNNIE WALKER BLACK
GLENLIVET 12 YR
GREY GOOSE
GIN
BLUECOAT
TANQUERAY
HENDRICK’S
EMPRESS 1908
WHISKY
SEAGRAM’S 7
CROWN ROYAL
CROWN ROYAL REGAL APPLE
JAMESON
FIREBALL
RUM
BACARDI SUPERIORJOVEN
BACARDI COCONUT
CAPTAIN MORGAN SPICED
GOSLING’S BLACK SEAL
TEQUILA & MEZCAL
CORAZON BLANCO
TANTEO JALAPENO
CASAMIGOS BLANCO
PATRON SILVER
SOLENTO ORGANIC BLANCO
SOLENTO ORGANIC REPOSADO
SOLENTO ORGANIC ANEJO
DON JULIO 1942
ILEGAL MEZCAL JOVEN
BOURBON, RYE, TENNESSEE WHISKY
JIM BEAM
SAZERAC RYE
BUFFALO TRACE
JACK DANIELS
BULLEIT BOURBON
BULLEIT RYE
MAKER’S MARK
BLANTON’S SINGLE BARREL
SCOTCH
DEWAR’S
JOHNNIE WALKER BLACK
GLENLIVET 12 YR
TANQUERAY
HENDRICK’S
EMPRESS 1908
WHISKY
SEAGRAM’S 7
CROWN ROYAL
CROWN ROYAL REGAL APPLE
JAMESON
FIREBALL
RUM
BACARDI SUPERIORJOVEN
BACARDI COCONUT
CAPTAIN MORGAN SPICED
GOSLING’S BLACK SEAL
TEQUILA & MEZCAL
CORAZON BLANCO
TANTEO JALAPENO
CASAMIGOS BLANCO
PATRON SILVER
SOLENTO ORGANIC BLANCO
SOLENTO ORGANIC REPOSADO
SOLENTO ORGANIC ANEJO
DON JULIO 1942
ILEGAL MEZCAL JOVEN
BOURBON, RYE, TENNESSEE WHISKY
JIM BEAM
SAZERAC RYE
BUFFALO TRACE
JACK DANIELS
BULLEIT BOURBON
BULLEIT RYE
MAKER’S MARK
BLANTON’S SINGLE BARREL
SCOTCH
DEWAR’S
JOHNNIE WALKER BLACK
GLENLIVET 12 YR
EMPRESS 1908
WHISKY
SEAGRAM’S 7
CROWN ROYAL
CROWN ROYAL REGAL APPLE
JAMESON
FIREBALL
RUM
BACARDI SUPERIORJOVEN
BACARDI COCONUT
CAPTAIN MORGAN SPICED
GOSLING’S BLACK SEAL
TEQUILA & MEZCAL
CORAZON BLANCO
TANTEO JALAPENO
CASAMIGOS BLANCO
PATRON SILVER
SOLENTO ORGANIC BLANCO
SOLENTO ORGANIC REPOSADO
SOLENTO ORGANIC ANEJO
DON JULIO 1942
ILEGAL MEZCAL JOVEN
BOURBON, RYE, TENNESSEE WHISKY
JIM BEAM
SAZERAC RYE
BUFFALO TRACE
JACK DANIELS
BULLEIT BOURBON
BULLEIT RYE
MAKER’S MARK
BLANTON’S SINGLE BARREL
SCOTCH
DEWAR’S
JOHNNIE WALKER BLACK
GLENLIVET 12 YR
CROWN ROYAL
CROWN ROYAL REGAL APPLE
JAMESON
FIREBALL
RUM
BACARDI SUPERIORJOVEN
BACARDI COCONUT
CAPTAIN MORGAN SPICED
GOSLING’S BLACK SEAL
TEQUILA & MEZCAL
CORAZON BLANCO
TANTEO JALAPENO
CASAMIGOS BLANCO
PATRON SILVER
SOLENTO ORGANIC BLANCO
SOLENTO ORGANIC REPOSADO
SOLENTO ORGANIC ANEJO
DON JULIO 1942
ILEGAL MEZCAL JOVEN
BOURBON, RYE, TENNESSEE WHISKY
JIM BEAM
SAZERAC RYE
BUFFALO TRACE
JACK DANIELS
BULLEIT BOURBON
BULLEIT RYE
MAKER’S MARK
BLANTON’S SINGLE BARREL
SCOTCH
DEWAR’S
JOHNNIE WALKER BLACK
GLENLIVET 12 YR
JAMESON
FIREBALL
RUM
BACARDI SUPERIORJOVEN
BACARDI COCONUT
CAPTAIN MORGAN SPICED
GOSLING’S BLACK SEAL
TEQUILA & MEZCAL
CORAZON BLANCO
TANTEO JALAPENO
CASAMIGOS BLANCO
PATRON SILVER
SOLENTO ORGANIC BLANCO
SOLENTO ORGANIC REPOSADO
SOLENTO ORGANIC ANEJO
DON JULIO 1942
ILEGAL MEZCAL JOVEN
BOURBON, RYE, TENNESSEE WHISKY
JIM BEAM
SAZERAC RYE
BUFFALO TRACE
JACK DANIELS
BULLEIT BOURBON
BULLEIT RYE
MAKER’S MARK
BLANTON’S SINGLE BARREL
SCOTCH
DEWAR’S
JOHNNIE WALKER BLACK
GLENLIVET 12 YR
RUM
BACARDI SUPERIORJOVEN
BACARDI COCONUT
CAPTAIN MORGAN SPICED
GOSLING’S BLACK SEAL
TEQUILA & MEZCAL
CORAZON BLANCO
TANTEO JALAPENO
CASAMIGOS BLANCO
PATRON SILVER
SOLENTO ORGANIC BLANCO
SOLENTO ORGANIC REPOSADO
SOLENTO ORGANIC ANEJO
DON JULIO 1942
ILEGAL MEZCAL JOVEN
BOURBON, RYE, TENNESSEE WHISKY
JIM BEAM
SAZERAC RYE
BUFFALO TRACE
JACK DANIELS
BULLEIT BOURBON
BULLEIT RYE
MAKER’S MARK
BLANTON’S SINGLE BARREL
SCOTCH
DEWAR’S
JOHNNIE WALKER BLACK
GLENLIVET 12 YR
CAPTAIN MORGAN SPICED
GOSLING’S BLACK SEAL
TEQUILA & MEZCAL
CORAZON BLANCO
TANTEO JALAPENO
CASAMIGOS BLANCO
PATRON SILVER
SOLENTO ORGANIC BLANCO
SOLENTO ORGANIC REPOSADO
SOLENTO ORGANIC ANEJO
DON JULIO 1942
ILEGAL MEZCAL JOVEN
BOURBON, RYE, TENNESSEE WHISKY
JIM BEAM
SAZERAC RYE
BUFFALO TRACE
JACK DANIELS
BULLEIT BOURBON
BULLEIT RYE
MAKER’S MARK
BLANTON’S SINGLE BARREL
SCOTCH
DEWAR’S
JOHNNIE WALKER BLACK
GLENLIVET 12 YR
TEQUILA & MEZCAL
CORAZON BLANCO
TANTEO JALAPENO
CASAMIGOS BLANCO
PATRON SILVER
SOLENTO ORGANIC BLANCO
SOLENTO ORGANIC REPOSADO
SOLENTO ORGANIC ANEJO
DON JULIO 1942
ILEGAL MEZCAL JOVEN
BOURBON, RYE, TENNESSEE WHISKY
JIM BEAM
SAZERAC RYE
BUFFALO TRACE
JACK DANIELS
BULLEIT BOURBON
BULLEIT RYE
MAKER’S MARK
BLANTON’S SINGLE BARREL
SCOTCH
DEWAR’S
JOHNNIE WALKER BLACK
GLENLIVET 12 YR
CASAMIGOS BLANCO
PATRON SILVER
SOLENTO ORGANIC BLANCO
SOLENTO ORGANIC REPOSADO
SOLENTO ORGANIC ANEJO
DON JULIO 1942
ILEGAL MEZCAL JOVEN
BOURBON, RYE, TENNESSEE WHISKY
JIM BEAM
SAZERAC RYE
BUFFALO TRACE
JACK DANIELS
BULLEIT BOURBON
BULLEIT RYE
MAKER’S MARK
BLANTON’S SINGLE BARREL
SCOTCH
DEWAR’S
JOHNNIE WALKER BLACK
GLENLIVET 12 YR
SOLENTO ORGANIC BLANCO
SOLENTO ORGANIC REPOSADO
SOLENTO ORGANIC ANEJO
DON JULIO 1942
ILEGAL MEZCAL JOVEN
BOURBON, RYE, TENNESSEE WHISKY
JIM BEAM
SAZERAC RYE
BUFFALO TRACE
JACK DANIELS
BULLEIT BOURBON
BULLEIT RYE
MAKER’S MARK
BLANTON’S SINGLE BARREL
SCOTCH
DEWAR’S
JOHNNIE WALKER BLACK
GLENLIVET 12 YR
SOLENTO ORGANIC ANEJO
DON JULIO 1942
ILEGAL MEZCAL JOVEN
BOURBON, RYE, TENNESSEE WHISKY
JIM BEAM
SAZERAC RYE
BUFFALO TRACE
JACK DANIELS
BULLEIT BOURBON
BULLEIT RYE
MAKER’S MARK
BLANTON’S SINGLE BARREL
SCOTCH
DEWAR’S
JOHNNIE WALKER BLACK
GLENLIVET 12 YR
ILEGAL MEZCAL JOVEN
BOURBON, RYE, TENNESSEE WHISKY
JIM BEAM
SAZERAC RYE
BUFFALO TRACE
JACK DANIELS
BULLEIT BOURBON
BULLEIT RYE
MAKER’S MARK
BLANTON’S SINGLE BARREL
SCOTCH
DEWAR’S
JOHNNIE WALKER BLACK
GLENLIVET 12 YR
SAZERAC RYE
BUFFALO TRACE
JACK DANIELS
BULLEIT BOURBON
BULLEIT RYE
MAKER’S MARK
BLANTON’S SINGLE BARREL
SCOTCH
DEWAR’S
JOHNNIE WALKER BLACK
GLENLIVET 12 YR
JACK DANIELS
BULLEIT BOURBON
BULLEIT RYE
MAKER’S MARK
BLANTON’S SINGLE BARREL
SCOTCH
DEWAR’S
JOHNNIE WALKER BLACK
GLENLIVET 12 YR
BULLEIT RYE
MAKER’S MARK
BLANTON’S SINGLE BARREL
SCOTCH
DEWAR’S
JOHNNIE WALKER BLACK
GLENLIVET 12 YR
BLANTON’S SINGLE BARREL
SCOTCH
DEWAR’S
JOHNNIE WALKER BLACK
GLENLIVET 12 YR
JOHNNIE WALKER BLACK
GLENLIVET 12 YR
*Menu prices and menu items are subject to change without prior notice.
*children 12 and under
HOT DOG & FRIES12
MAC & CHEESE12
MINI PIZZA12
CRISPY CHICKEN FINGERS & FRIES14
SPAGHETTI12
served with red sauce or butter
*Menu prices and menu items are subject to change without prior notice.
KEY LIME PIE11
DOUBLE CHOCOLATE BROWNIE A LA MODE12
double chocolate brownie served with vanilla ice cream and fresh berries
CHOCOLATE CHIP COOKIE ICE CREAM SANDWICH10
BEACH PLUM FARM FRESH BERRY COBBLER12
fresh berries from our own beach plum farm, with a granola brown sugar topping
*Menu prices and menu items are subject to change without prior notice.
ALL-NATURAL PUP TREATS7
our treats contain all human grade products—no byproducts, artificial colors, flavor or preservatives! These gourmet treats are made with 100% whole grains, real eggs, real cheese, real bacon and fresh ground peanuts.
DOGGIE BOWL
grilled chicken 8
steamed veggies 7
NAIL BURGER9
plain all-beef hamburger without the bun
HOT DIGGITY-DOG7
plain all-beef hot dog without the bun
*Menu prices and menu items are subject to change without prior notice.
The Rusty Nail is proud to be a Travel & Leisure Pick for One of America's Top 10 Beach Bars.
The Rusty Nail
205 Beach Avenue
Cape May, New Jersey 08204
it’s easy to find us
Cape May is easily accessible from the Garden State Parkway and the Cape May-Lewes Ferry. The Rusty Nail is located on Beach Avenue at the Beach Shack Hotel.
Parking is available in the spaces directly in front of the restaurant.
Parking is first-come, first-serve. Metered parking is available along Beach Avenue.
From Google Maps:
View Google Map & Enter Your Starting PointFrom Specific Points
From The Garden State Parkway | From The Cape May Lewes Ferry | From New York | From Washington/Baltimore | From Philadelphia